I think there is a confusion between the subject and a solved question.
This subject is open-ended roughly up until the point that the product is actually released and everyone has the chance (or choice?) to test it for themselves (or condemn it for eternity from their systems). However, this forum is a question & answer forum. So, if anyone asks a question and views the answers received to completely satisfy their needs, for them the question is closed since the answers are all they wanted to get and they can mark it as such.
I do not aim to be(come) a moderator, but personally the idea of yours to create an own thread sounds reasonable to me.