Does not wake-up after standby/freeze sometimes after recent update (AMD)

rugk · September 29, 2023, 8:51pm

Describe the bug
After updating from 38.20230920.0 to 38.20230927.0 (I am almost sure it has happened since that update), my laptop often seems to be stuck with a black screen (/in standby) when I try to wake it up from standby. It is, as if it does not react on the press of the power-button. Then, I often need to force-reboot it (via the power button), which is unfortunate.
Has happened like I dunno two times maybe now?

Also, possibly related, it froze one time just now when I had an external display connected via HDMI (no adapter, HDMI port at laptop) and USB-C for power delivery at the same time, the power plug may have disconnected and caused this issue). I also had to force reboot.

Never had that before, it is quite out of the sudden that these issues happen…

To Reproduce
Try the versions. Likely component- or device-specific.

Expected behavior
Not hang.

Screenshots
N/A

OS version:

State: idle
AutomaticUpdates: stage; rpm-ostreed-automatic.timer: last run 1h 38min ago
BootedDeployment:
● fedora:fedora/38/x86_64/silverblue
                  Version: 38.20230927.0 (2023-09-27T02:13:44Z)
               BaseCommit: 84a1d651086ddda05cdcd52167919f11688f7c9283687e97118c1f7336284a66
             GPGSignature: Valid signature by 6A51BBABBA3D5467B6171221809A8D7CEB10B464
          LayeredPackages: adb blivet-gui btop dconf-editor firewall-config git git-credential-libsecret *** nvme-cli openssl
                           pipewire-codec-aptx podman-compose rpmfusion-free-release simple-scan smartmontools sushi
                           tldr zsh

Additional context

● fedora:fedora/38/x86_64/silverblue (index: 1)
                  Version: 38.20230927.0 (2023-09-27T02:13:44Z)
               BaseCommit: 84a1d651086ddda05cdcd52167919f11688f7c9283687e97118c1f7336284a66
                           ├─ repo-0 (2023-04-13T20:37:10Z)
                           ├─ repo-1 (2023-09-27T01:40:03Z)
                           └─ repo-2 (2023-09-27T01:43:59Z)
                   Commit: dea94825e0db2170bba66011a2eac7492fef2df1a7af87d61160d325f4bd8e9a
                           ├─ fedora (2023-04-13T20:37:10Z)
                           ├─ fedora-cisco-openh264 (2023-03-14T10:56:46Z)
                           ├─ fedora-modular (2023-04-13T20:30:47Z)
                           ├─ rpmfusion-free (2023-04-14T11:37:11Z)
                           ├─ rpmfusion-free-updates (2023-09-26T11:20:14Z)
                           ├─ updates (2023-09-27T02:38:11Z)
                           ├─ updates-archive (2023-09-26T01:48:51Z)
                           └─ updates-modular (2023-09-16T00:25:03Z)
                StateRoot: fedora
             GPGSignature: 1 signature
                           Signature made Mi 27 Sep 2023 04:13:48 CEST using RSA key ID 809A8D7CEB10B464
                           Good signature from "Fedora <fedora-38-primary@fedoraproject.org>"
          LayeredPackages: adb blivet-gui btop dconf-editor firewall-config git git-credential-libsecret *** nvme-cli openssl
                           pipewire-codec-aptx podman-compose rpmfusion-free-release simple-scan smartmontools sushi
                           tldr zsh                   

  fedora:fedora/38/x86_64/silverblue (index: 2)
                  Version: 38.20230920.0 (2023-09-20T00:52:52Z)
               BaseCommit: 5fbec9c2714ffb9ee8a73093fbb101b707e59164d689b7c0057c7d8dadc23712
                           ├─ repo-0 (2023-04-13T20:37:10Z)
                           ├─ repo-1 (2023-09-20T00:16:59Z)
                           └─ repo-2 (2023-09-20T00:20:15Z)
                   Commit: 9eecd46a39435af7169b008c2a00b1fb253e388cdc62d5acafeeb0bb2e9dd1b6
                           ├─ fedora (2023-04-13T20:37:10Z)
                           ├─ fedora-cisco-openh264 (2023-03-14T10:56:46Z)
                           ├─ fedora-modular (2023-04-13T20:30:47Z)
                           ├─ rpmfusion-free (2023-04-14T11:37:11Z)
                           ├─ rpmfusion-free-updates (2023-09-14T21:01:39Z)
                           ├─ updates (2023-09-20T01:22:56Z)
                           ├─ updates-archive (2023-09-20T02:19:42Z)
                           └─ updates-modular (2023-09-16T00:25:03Z)
                StateRoot: fedora
             GPGSignature: 1 signature
                           Signature made Mi 20 Sep 2023 02:52:57 CEST using RSA key ID 809A8D7CEB10B464
                           Good signature from "Fedora <fedora-38-primary@fedoraproject.org>"
          LayeredPackages: adb blivet-gui btop dconf-editor firewall-config git git-credential-libsecret *** nvme-cli openssl
                           pipewire-codec-aptx podman-compose rpmfusion-free-release simple-scan smartmontools sushi
                           tldr zsh

As there were some firmware and kernel updates, I suspect this may be related to the software/updates:

$ rpm-ostree db diff 9eecd46a39435af7169b008c2a00b1fb253e388cdc62d5acafeeb0bb2e9dd1b6 dea94825e0db2170bba66011a2eac7492fef2df1a7af87d61160d325f4bd8e9a
ostree diff commit from: 9eecd46a39435af7169b008c2a00b1fb253e388cdc62d5acafeeb0bb2e9dd1b6
ostree diff commit to:   dea94825e0db2170bba66011a2eac7492fef2df1a7af87d61160d325f4bd8e9a
Upgraded:
  amd-gpu-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38
  atheros-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38
  brcmfmac-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38
  container-selinux 2:2.221.1-1.fc38 -> 2:2.222.0-1.fc38
  cups 1:2.4.6-4.fc38 -> 1:2.4.7-1.fc38
  cups-client 1:2.4.6-4.fc38 -> 1:2.4.7-1.fc38
  cups-filesystem 1:2.4.6-4.fc38 -> 1:2.4.7-1.fc38
  cups-ipptool 1:2.4.6-4.fc38 -> 1:2.4.7-1.fc38
  cups-libs 1:2.4.6-4.fc38 -> 1:2.4.7-1.fc38
  gstreamer1 1.22.5-1.fc38 -> 1.22.6-1.fc38
  intel-gpu-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38
  iwlegacy-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38
  iwlwifi-dvm-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38
  iwlwifi-mvm-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38
  kernel 6.4.15-200.fc38 -> 6.5.5-200.fc38
  kernel-core 6.4.15-200.fc38 -> 6.5.5-200.fc38
  kernel-modules 6.4.15-200.fc38 -> 6.5.5-200.fc38
  kernel-modules-core 6.4.15-200.fc38 -> 6.5.5-200.fc38
  kernel-modules-extra 6.4.15-200.fc38 -> 6.5.5-200.fc38
  langtable 0.0.63-1.fc38 -> 0.0.64-1.fc38
  libertas-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38
  libppd 1:2.0~rc2-3.fc38 -> 1:2.0~rc2-4.fc38
  libwebp 1.3.1-3.fc38 -> 1.3.2-1.fc38
  linux-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38
  linux-firmware-whence 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38
  mesa-dri-drivers 23.1.7-1.fc38 -> 23.1.8-1.fc38
  mesa-filesystem 23.1.7-1.fc38 -> 23.1.8-1.fc38
  mesa-libEGL 23.1.7-1.fc38 -> 23.1.8-1.fc38
  mesa-libGL 23.1.7-1.fc38 -> 23.1.8-1.fc38
  mesa-libgbm 23.1.7-1.fc38 -> 23.1.8-1.fc38
  mesa-libglapi 23.1.7-1.fc38 -> 23.1.8-1.fc38
  mesa-libxatracker 23.1.7-1.fc38 -> 23.1.8-1.fc38
  mesa-va-drivers 23.1.7-1.fc38 -> 23.1.8-1.fc38
  mesa-vulkan-drivers 23.1.7-1.fc38 -> 23.1.8-1.fc38
  mt7xxx-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38
  nvidia-gpu-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38
  pipewire-codec-aptx 0.3.79-1.fc38 -> 0.3.80-1.fc38
  python3-langtable 0.0.63-1.fc38 -> 0.0.64-1.fc38
  realtek-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38
  vim-data 2:9.0.1872-1.fc38 -> 2:9.0.1927-1.fc38
  vim-minimal 2:9.0.1872-1.fc38 -> 2:9.0.1927-1.fc38
  zip 3.0-36.fc38 -> 3.0-37.fc38

I have pinned the old deployment for now.
And no sorry did not have time to install Fedora Workstation to reproduce it there…

device

Lenovo IdeaPad 5 15ARE05
CPU: AMD Ryzen 7 4800U with Radeon Graphics
GPU: none (integrated)

Full lshw output: lshw · GitHub

Cross-posted to the Silverblue issue tracker.

vwbusguy · October 2, 2023, 5:00pm

Silverblue is fully supported here. No need to install/test on Workstation.

Can you try running journalctl --boot -1 | tail -500 and see if there are any relevant errors related to suspend, power, GPU, etc., and post those logs here as well?

Does it happen if you boot to a previous kernel?

Incidentally, I also have a Ryzen 4800U with Workstation on it - so I might try updating and testing this as well after a bit.

EDIT: Suspend works for me here on kernel 6.5.5-200.fc38.x86_64 with two attached external monitors. I did recently accept the new suspend style via fwupdmgron this machine, which may or may not be relevant.

jlinton · October 3, 2023, 1:51am

I’ve been having hit/miss suspsend/resume problems all year across various kernels (some work, some work sometimes, some not at all). The one thing that seems to fix it frequently is amd_iommu=off on the grub/kernel command line.

See if that fixes it, other than a small issue I found in the driver (not really sure if its related, I poked the maintainer but have yet to hear back, probably will post it on the ML soon), the fixes in working kernels have overwhelmingly been amdgpu bugs.

rugk · October 3, 2023, 8:33pm

People on GitHub seem to confirm this may be a kernel regression:

github.com/fedora-silverblue/issue-tracker

Does not wake-up after standby/freeze sometimes after recent update (AMD)

opened 08:48PM - 29 Sep 23 UTC

rugk

bug f38

**Describe the bug** After updating from 38.20230920.0 to 38.20230927.0 (I am a…lmost sure it has happened since that update), my laptop often seems to be stuck with a black screen (/in standby) when I try to wake it up from standby. It is, as if it does not react on the press of the power-button. Then, I often need to force-reboot it (via the power button), which is unfortunate. Has happened like I dunno two times maybe now? Also, possibly related, it froze one time just now when I had an external display connected via HDMI (no adapter, HDMI port at laptop) and USB-C for power delivery at the same time, the power plug may have disconnected and caused this issue). I also had to force reboot. Never had that before, it is quite out of the sudden that these issues happen… **To Reproduce** Try the versions. Likely component- or device-specific. **Expected behavior** Not hang. **Screenshots** N/A **OS version:** ``` State: idle AutomaticUpdates: stage; rpm-ostreed-automatic.timer: last run 1h 38min ago BootedDeployment: ● fedora:fedora/38/x86_64/silverblue Version: 38.20230927.0 (2023-09-27T02:13:44Z) BaseCommit: 84a1d651086ddda05cdcd52167919f11688f7c9283687e97118c1f7336284a66 GPGSignature: Valid signature by 6A51BBABBA3D5467B6171221809A8D7CEB10B464 LayeredPackages: adb blivet-gui btop dconf-editor firewall-config git git-credential-libsecret *** nvme-cli openssl pipewire-codec-aptx podman-compose rpmfusion-free-release simple-scan smartmontools sushi tldr zsh ``` **Additional context** ``` ● fedora:fedora/38/x86_64/silverblue (index: 1) Version: 38.20230927.0 (2023-09-27T02:13:44Z) BaseCommit: 84a1d651086ddda05cdcd52167919f11688f7c9283687e97118c1f7336284a66 ├─ repo-0 (2023-04-13T20:37:10Z) ├─ repo-1 (2023-09-27T01:40:03Z) └─ repo-2 (2023-09-27T01:43:59Z) Commit: dea94825e0db2170bba66011a2eac7492fef2df1a7af87d61160d325f4bd8e9a ├─ fedora (2023-04-13T20:37:10Z) ├─ fedora-cisco-openh264 (2023-03-14T10:56:46Z) ├─ fedora-modular (2023-04-13T20:30:47Z) ├─ rpmfusion-free (2023-04-14T11:37:11Z) ├─ rpmfusion-free-updates (2023-09-26T11:20:14Z) ├─ updates (2023-09-27T02:38:11Z) ├─ updates-archive (2023-09-26T01:48:51Z) └─ updates-modular (2023-09-16T00:25:03Z) StateRoot: fedora GPGSignature: 1 signature Signature made Mi 27 Sep 2023 04:13:48 CEST using RSA key ID 809A8D7CEB10B464 Good signature from "Fedora <fedora-38-primary@fedoraproject.org>" LayeredPackages: adb blivet-gui btop dconf-editor firewall-config git git-credential-libsecret *** nvme-cli openssl pipewire-codec-aptx podman-compose rpmfusion-free-release simple-scan smartmontools sushi tldr zsh fedora:fedora/38/x86_64/silverblue (index: 2) Version: 38.20230920.0 (2023-09-20T00:52:52Z) BaseCommit: 5fbec9c2714ffb9ee8a73093fbb101b707e59164d689b7c0057c7d8dadc23712 ├─ repo-0 (2023-04-13T20:37:10Z) ├─ repo-1 (2023-09-20T00:16:59Z) └─ repo-2 (2023-09-20T00:20:15Z) Commit: 9eecd46a39435af7169b008c2a00b1fb253e388cdc62d5acafeeb0bb2e9dd1b6 ├─ fedora (2023-04-13T20:37:10Z) ├─ fedora-cisco-openh264 (2023-03-14T10:56:46Z) ├─ fedora-modular (2023-04-13T20:30:47Z) ├─ rpmfusion-free (2023-04-14T11:37:11Z) ├─ rpmfusion-free-updates (2023-09-14T21:01:39Z) ├─ updates (2023-09-20T01:22:56Z) ├─ updates-archive (2023-09-20T02:19:42Z) └─ updates-modular (2023-09-16T00:25:03Z) StateRoot: fedora GPGSignature: 1 signature Signature made Mi 20 Sep 2023 02:52:57 CEST using RSA key ID 809A8D7CEB10B464 Good signature from "Fedora <fedora-38-primary@fedoraproject.org>" LayeredPackages: adb blivet-gui btop dconf-editor firewall-config git git-credential-libsecret *** nvme-cli openssl pipewire-codec-aptx podman-compose rpmfusion-free-release simple-scan smartmontools sushi tldr zsh ``` As there were some firmware and kernel updates, I suspect this may be related to the software/updates: ``` $ rpm-ostree db diff 9eecd46a39435af7169b008c2a00b1fb253e388cdc62d5acafeeb0bb2e9dd1b6 dea94825e0db2170bba66011a2eac7492fef2df1a7af87d61160d325f4bd8e9a ostree diff commit from: 9eecd46a39435af7169b008c2a00b1fb253e388cdc62d5acafeeb0bb2e9dd1b6 ostree diff commit to: dea94825e0db2170bba66011a2eac7492fef2df1a7af87d61160d325f4bd8e9a Upgraded: amd-gpu-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38 atheros-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38 brcmfmac-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38 container-selinux 2:2.221.1-1.fc38 -> 2:2.222.0-1.fc38 cups 1:2.4.6-4.fc38 -> 1:2.4.7-1.fc38 cups-client 1:2.4.6-4.fc38 -> 1:2.4.7-1.fc38 cups-filesystem 1:2.4.6-4.fc38 -> 1:2.4.7-1.fc38 cups-ipptool 1:2.4.6-4.fc38 -> 1:2.4.7-1.fc38 cups-libs 1:2.4.6-4.fc38 -> 1:2.4.7-1.fc38 gstreamer1 1.22.5-1.fc38 -> 1.22.6-1.fc38 intel-gpu-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38 iwlegacy-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38 iwlwifi-dvm-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38 iwlwifi-mvm-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38 kernel 6.4.15-200.fc38 -> 6.5.5-200.fc38 kernel-core 6.4.15-200.fc38 -> 6.5.5-200.fc38 kernel-modules 6.4.15-200.fc38 -> 6.5.5-200.fc38 kernel-modules-core 6.4.15-200.fc38 -> 6.5.5-200.fc38 kernel-modules-extra 6.4.15-200.fc38 -> 6.5.5-200.fc38 langtable 0.0.63-1.fc38 -> 0.0.64-1.fc38 libertas-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38 libppd 1:2.0~rc2-3.fc38 -> 1:2.0~rc2-4.fc38 libwebp 1.3.1-3.fc38 -> 1.3.2-1.fc38 linux-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38 linux-firmware-whence 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38 mesa-dri-drivers 23.1.7-1.fc38 -> 23.1.8-1.fc38 mesa-filesystem 23.1.7-1.fc38 -> 23.1.8-1.fc38 mesa-libEGL 23.1.7-1.fc38 -> 23.1.8-1.fc38 mesa-libGL 23.1.7-1.fc38 -> 23.1.8-1.fc38 mesa-libgbm 23.1.7-1.fc38 -> 23.1.8-1.fc38 mesa-libglapi 23.1.7-1.fc38 -> 23.1.8-1.fc38 mesa-libxatracker 23.1.7-1.fc38 -> 23.1.8-1.fc38 mesa-va-drivers 23.1.7-1.fc38 -> 23.1.8-1.fc38 mesa-vulkan-drivers 23.1.7-1.fc38 -> 23.1.8-1.fc38 mt7xxx-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38 nvidia-gpu-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38 pipewire-codec-aptx 0.3.79-1.fc38 -> 0.3.80-1.fc38 python3-langtable 0.0.63-1.fc38 -> 0.0.64-1.fc38 realtek-firmware 20230804-153.fc38 -> 20230919-1.fc38 vim-data 2:9.0.1872-1.fc38 -> 2:9.0.1927-1.fc38 vim-minimal 2:9.0.1872-1.fc38 -> 2:9.0.1927-1.fc38 zip 3.0-36.fc38 -> 3.0-37.fc38 ``` I have pinned the old deployment for now. And no sorry did not have time to install Fedora Workstation to reproduce it there… :see_no_evil: ## device Lenovo IdeaPad 5 15ARE05 CPU: AMD Ryzen 7 4800U with Radeon Graphics GPU: none (integrated) Full `lshw` output: https://gist.github.com/rugk/d6517f7309a9ceedadaf929daf3e00be --- Cross-posted [to AskFedora](https://discussion.fedoraproject.org/t/does-not-wake-up-after-standby-freeze-sometimes-after-recent-update-amd/91109?u=rugk).

rugk · October 3, 2023, 9:06pm

Issue is tracked in https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=2240859 and apparently fixed in kernel v6.5.6.