Drop Mandatory Requires on JRE
This is a proposed Change for Fedora Linux.
This document represents a proposed Change. As part of the Changes process, proposals are publicly announced in order to receive community feedback. This proposal will only be implemented if approved by the Fedora Engineering Steering Committee.
Summary
Drop the requirement of Java libraries to have Requires on JREs.
Owner
- Name: Marián Konček
- Email: mkoncek@redhat.com
Detailed Description
Current guidelines require all Java packages to Require: java-headless or java-headless >= 1:minimal_required_version
.
Our aim is to drop this explicit requirement on Java library packages. The requirement should stay for Java applications.
Context
Java packages are compiled using javac
into .class
files and composed into .jar
archives. Jar archives can be used as compile or runtime dependencies for other packages or can be directly executed with the java command provided by a JRE.
Jar archives can be executed using the command: java -jar ${FILE}
. This command executes the main
method either specified via CLI or specified within the Jar manifest file.
Java packages, which serve as libraries only, lack the main
method and are not executable. Therefore, there is no requirement on any specific JRE imposed by the library implicitly.
Different JDKs
This proposal is also related to the topic of different JDKs. Developers may want to use or build packages which use a JDK different than the one provided by the java-<N>-openjdk
package. After this proposal was implemented, they would be able to depend on Java library packages with no introduction of the OpenJDK package.
Rationale
Java libraries are more similar to native libraries than to libraries written in dynamic scripting languages. They are compiled to a bytecode and are not executable. Java libraries can be used as dependencies for any Java application and there is no implicit dependency on the system default JDK.
Java applications, on the other hand, are expected to be tested and to work with the system JDK and from the user’s perspective: after installing an application they must be able to simply run the binary. Therefore the Requires
on the system JDK is kept for Java applications.
Feedback
Benefit to Fedora
- Very little user-visible benefit.
- Reduced dependencies of Java packages.
- Simplified maintenance of Java packages.
- Smaller impact of JDK major updates (e.g.
1.8.0 -> 11 -> 17 -> 21
). Introducing a new system version of JDK requires the rebuild of each Java package in order to have updatedRequires
to contain the newest version.
- Smaller impact of JDK major updates (e.g.
Scope
-
Proposal owners:
- Find all Java applications in Fedora, i.e. packages which
BuildRequire
java-devel / maven-local / ant
and at the same time install files into/bin
or/sbin
or/usr/bin
or/usr/sbin
. - Open pull requests adding
Requires: java-headless
into their.spec
file. - Remove
Requires
generator from javapackages-tools - Wait for a mass rebuild.
- Find all Java applications in Fedora, i.e. packages which
-
Other developers:
- Maintainers of Java applications will need to add an explicit
Requires: java-headless
field into their.spec
file or a specific version of thereof (such asjava-17-openjdk-headless
).
- Maintainers of Java applications will need to add an explicit
-
Release engineering: #12069
- Mass rebuild is not required, this change can propagate via natural rebuilds.
-
Policies and guidelines:
- Guidelines need to be modified (open Pull Request).
-
Trademark approval: N/A (not needed for this Change)
-
Alignment with Community Initiatives: N/A
Upgrade/compatibility impact
-
For Java libraries:
- This change is removing
Requires
and therefore users manually installing a Java library will not additionally install the JVM.
- This change is removing
-
For Java applications:
- After fully implemented, applications will no longer be installable along with any JVM but rather only the system one (unless the package maintainer decides otherwise)
How To Test
- Installing a Java library should not typically install JVM (but can if the library depends on a Java application)
- Installing a Java application MUST cause the installation of the system-wide JVM (or a different version thereof)
- Executing a binary installed in typical locations (such as
/usr/bin
) MUST NOT cause an error related to the JVM not being installed.
User Experience
Users with no Java application installed, but some Java libraries installed: the JVM may be automatically uninstalled as it is possibly not required by anything.
It is possible that there are users with only some older JVM installed. The following depends on the decision of each Java application package maintainer, but the general expectation is that the system-wide JVM will be installed and the older JVM will no longer be required by other packages.
Users who explicitly installed JVMs of various versions: no change.
Dependencies
-
javapackages-tools
- This change allows the removal of the
Requires
generator.
- This change allows the removal of the
Contingency Plan
-
Contingency mechanism:
- In case of unexpected problems, the
Requires
generators can be reintroduced intojavapackages-tools
and packages can be rebuilt.
- In case of unexpected problems, the
-
Contingency deadline: Branch Fedora Linux 41 from Rawhide Tue 2024-08-06
-
Blocks release? No
Documentation
No documentation outside of this document.
Release Notes
Last edited by @amoloney 2024-04-25T08:48:37Z