I am working on creating a chat icon for the Quality Assurance team. I have some iterations and I’d like to know which ones are preferred by the team and community.
These are meant for the Matrix channels we have on Fedora.im… and I think you should take a look at them at the final scale they would show up as in the Element chat client. They look like they are probably too detailed to read well at scale. You have a lot of fine details in the badge in the lower right corner - a lot of spokes on the circle and fine detalis in the ribbon, for instance. That won’t really be readable at scale. I would simplify this design a lot to make sure it’s readable.