Fedora 44, Gnome 50, and Papers 49

Since Fedora 44 has now been released, ostensibly with GNOME 50, could we expect Papers 50 to make an appearance soon? Papers 49 is still lacking in text and other annotations, so Papers 50 would be a boon.

don’t know but in the meantime you can install the flatpak from https://flathub.org/en/apps/org.gnome.Papers (currently v.50.1) or the nightly flatpak from Welcome to GNOME – Document Viewer

Bumping this thread. Any news on this? Why would Papers not be updated on the fedora flatpak?

Fedora Flatpaks are re-packaged from Fedora RPMs. So the real question is why the RPM version is old. I don’t know the answer to that.

Last I heard, the team were waiting on rust dependences getting packaged for Fedora but I’m not certain on the status of those.

Help welcome. It’s written in Rust, so almost all of the GNOME packagers will just ignore it. I certainly won’t touch the Rust packages. They are a tremendous pain to update.

We do try to keep everything that is not Rust nicely updated.

hmm, I think I’ll just switch to the flathub package then, I don’t really get what users are getting out of those fedora packages vs. the flathub ones. Why go through this pain at all?

We don’t have Flathub enabled in Fedora Workstation.

And it’s installed by default, because a PDF viewer is nice to have. Even if we were to enable Flathub by default in the future, we still won’t ship preinstalled apps from Flathub. Fedora needs to build its own preinstalled apps.

I see. But it doesn’t really seem to be maintanable. Not only are users getting Fedora packages with their OS installation, they also have to get all of the future updates of these packages through Fedora and therefore become fully dependent on Fedora to do the job of delivering those packages. Worse, some of these packages are unfortunately crippled compared to the flathub ones (e.g. no codecs). When I first started using Fedora, I was in a complete state of confusion about all this. I hope there is a future where Fedora simply offers a “starter pack” of applications to get from flathup during a post-installation onboarding or something similar.

Purpose of distros isn’t to do things that make sense and are maintainable, but reinvent the wheel :stuck_out_tongue:

Curious, I heard from someone else that Rust have one of the best toolings available in Fedora. So… who is right here?

Tooling is lovely. But of course the problem is dependencies.

Status update: Papers 50 is still blocked on dependencies.

Do you package every single dependency?

No. It’s very rare that I would volunteer to package something. I certainly won’t be packaging anything that uses Rust.

That said, in this case, somebody else is already willing to own most of the dependencies, but we need to first eliminate the unnecessary dependencies as suggested in the issue report I linked to in my previous post.

I meant whether Fedora packages all rust crates.

No - there are over 300,000 of them.

I am clearly not communicating myself well enough.

My question was whether Fedora packages every crate apps depend on.

Decisions to package and own a new dependency are handled on a case-by-case basis. In this case, the packager decided that adding 15 new dependencies seemed like overkill.

I guess it’s obvious that whenever any package adds a new dependency, distros have to decide whether to package it or not. GNOME projects usually add meson build options to ensure new dependencies are optional, because if not, you wind up in situations like this where the distro falls behind. (In this case, Debian and Fedora are both still stuck on Papers 49.)

Out of curiosity I installed Vanilla OS and it does exactly that. The post-install onboarding asks what to install and installs everything from flathub.

What you are saying doesnt makes sense friend. Rust static compiles. There arent dependencies.

Ive just compiled it. Flatpak has some issues wit filesystem.

Btw thats a shame it was not included in fedora as packages.