Can't choose XFBurn for“You have just inserted blank disc” menu

When I insert a blank disc into my reader, I see the following prompt:


However, when I change “Ask what to do” to “Other application [than Disk Writer]”, the list contains many programs—EXCEPT the one (XFBurn) that would actually be useful to auto-open when inserting a blank disc.

How can I manually change the program to be automatically opened when inserting a disc?